|
Post by Dave D-Flipz on Feb 11, 2020 8:07:13 GMT -5
if you want to claim a character, claim it. I really don't think a descriptor like "sexy" should be used because it is so objective. Not to judge, but spiderman isn't sexy to me anymore because he's supposed to be a high school boy and that's a bit young. Tiny Tom is cute like a puppy and I will give you adorable but not sexy. Hey that's ok yea just rip on your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man. Not like he has feelings or anything. He's probably got a girl anyway so ya know not that he would care. Is Mongo claiming cop? That's a bold and moderately dumb move. I'm willing to let this play out a bit. Still not sure how this game is going to go. So I'll Unvote
|
|
|
Post by Bobby Barratt on Feb 11, 2020 9:16:51 GMT -5
if you want to claim a character, claim it. I really don't think a descriptor like "sexy" should be used because it is so objective. Not to judge, but spiderman isn't sexy to me anymore because he's supposed to be a high school boy and that's a bit young. Tiny Tom is cute like a puppy and I will give you adorable but not sexy. Hey that's ok yea just rip on your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man. Not like he has feelings or anything. He's probably got a girl anyway so ya know not that he would care. Is Mongo claiming cop? That's a bold and moderately dumb move. I'm willing to let this play out a bit. Still not sure how this game is going to go. So I'll UnvoteIf this is a legit claim, despite being subtle then we have to treat it as truth until countered or proven otherwise. I have mongo in my town pile right now....slightly.
|
|
MYŌJIN
.::XHF Superstar::.
FKA Draven | Former X*Crown Champion | Former XHF JHW Champion
Posts: 836
|
Post by MYŌJIN on Feb 11, 2020 10:59:34 GMT -5
Greetings from Wakanda everyone!
Sorry I'm a bit late to the party, about to start reading up before I say much of anything else.
|
|
MYŌJIN
.::XHF Superstar::.
FKA Draven | Former X*Crown Champion | Former XHF JHW Champion
Posts: 836
|
Post by MYŌJIN on Feb 11, 2020 11:06:03 GMT -5
Okay so multiple people already started voting for Momgo. Not sure how I feel about that especially since it seems without reason, definitely seems like mafia is trying to get an easy kill because of the Fuck Mongo train.
H2F also voting for DT near-instantly without really much to go off besides past game is very shady. Hmm.
Seth has a point about the Soul Stone, and it does seem like Mongo is claiming he's a cop? Very interesting. He just basically outed himself as a target to attack, so while it can possibly prove his innocence- He may have just definitely screwed himself over for the upcoming night methinks.
Please correct me if I've read some things wrong.
|
|
h2f
CAR Pit Crew
Vroom, Vroom, Female Dogs
Posts: 1,381
|
Post by h2f on Feb 11, 2020 11:39:20 GMT -5
Okay so multiple people already started voting for Momgo. Not sure how I feel about that especially since it seems without reason, definitely seems like mafia is trying to get an easy kill because of the Fuck Mongo train. H2F also voting for DT near-instantly without really much to go off besides past game is very shady. Hmm. Seth has a point about the Soul Stone, and it does seem like Mongo is claiming he's a cop? Very interesting. He just basically outed himself as a target to attack, so while it can possibly prove his innocence- He may have just definitely screwed himself over for the upcoming night methinks. Please correct me if I've read some things wrong. I read mongo's ability not as a cop but as a statement checker. I don't want to presume though and it does seem very forward to come out with it in a vague way. Mongo could be scum but it's too soon to tell and I worry about a fast train like this day 1.
|
|
|
Post by Seth Dillinger on Feb 11, 2020 12:07:16 GMT -5
I think I am picking up on what Mongo is putting down with that sort of softclaim, and it isn't a cop. If it's what I think it is, then Mongo is quite smart to do what he's doing, actually. UNVOTEh2f reads as strong town to me right now. DT looks mostly good for at least bringing up the Soul Stone thing. So does johndoe -- I like that he's the only other person to engage in mechanical speculation with me about what to do with the Soul Stone. It feels like scum are maybe avoiding talking about the Soul Stone because they don't know whether it's the correct play or not? Which makes me FOS: Hype, Dunne, Ryan, BobbyI'm going to VOTE: Draven, however. I dislike that he basically starts spewing IIoA when he arrives in the thread. Like what did that summary post do? There are no opinions given, other than pointing out the obvious like "the Mongo wagon is without reason" (no shit, it's an RVS wagon) or "Seth has a point about the Soul Stone" (what point? I made two separate ones) or "Mongo claiming cop is very interesting" (this is nothing, this means nothing). Happy with my vote here for now.
|
|
|
Post by Dylan on Feb 11, 2020 12:12:36 GMT -5
Puts on his cape and proceeds to look FABULOUS.
I am burdened with glorious purpose. I also see a slight flaw in Seth's plan, if we never sacrifice someone for the soul stone, and big Ballsack chin kills us all, Thanos can just sacrifice one of his minions to get the souldbstone. With all of us dead, he will easily be able to collect all the stones with no resistance and *snap*.
|
|
|
Post by Dylan on Feb 11, 2020 12:25:43 GMT -5
Although honestly the non-sacrificing for a soul stone might honestly be the safest route to play. That way if scum want the stone they have to sacrifice one of their own and that would oust them. Unless the sacrificial stuff happens at night.
Going to reread the rules on the soul stone rq
|
|
|
Post by Dylan on Feb 11, 2020 12:38:11 GMT -5
- Now remember how I said one stone ISN'T give at game start? The one stone that isn't issued to a player is the Soul Stone. Here's how the Soul Stone works: Unless you have a power that can kill during the day (ex: Day Vig/Specific Scum - and I'm not guaranteeing this role will exist), someone must VOLUNTEER to be sacrificed to another player. The player sacrificed will NOT have their role revealed upon death. Okay, so someone must volunteer to be sacrificed and their role will not be revealed. If all of town can agree no one will sacrifice themselves for the stone then we'll be okay. And if someone does sacrifice themselves, we can assume affterwards that they were scum, and if they choose who the stone goes to that person is also probably good chance of being scum
|
|
|
Post by Hyperion on Feb 11, 2020 12:43:43 GMT -5
Mongo is Heimdall? I feel like he would be a great Galactus. Also are we supposed to be writing these in character? I've no idea how to do my one. Umm... Cartwheels, sexily if you want to claim a character, claim it. I really don't think a descriptor like "sexy" should be used because it is so objective. Not to judge, but spiderman isn't sexy to me anymore because he's supposed to be a high school boy and that's a bit young. Tiny Tom is cute like a puppy and I will give you adorable but not sexy. Tom Holland is sexy in his own way, I'm sure. But I was implying my character oozes more sex appeal through acrobatics and ferocious lust. Anyway, flicks out her retractable sword I do love a good Fuck Mongo wagon however as always Day One is a game of chance. I'm gonna leave my vote on Mongo until I read a bit more about what his powers are. If Heimdall can see everything, he'll be able to know who is town/ scum right? So a tracker power or something along those lines. If Mongo is scum he wouldn't need this power, so this leans towards a town power to me. But I'mma read up on this cos I haven't played in so long.
|
|
h2f
CAR Pit Crew
Vroom, Vroom, Female Dogs
Posts: 1,381
|
Post by h2f on Feb 11, 2020 12:47:24 GMT -5
- Now remember how I said one stone ISN'T give at game start? The one stone that isn't issued to a player is the Soul Stone. Here's how the Soul Stone works: Unless you have a power that can kill during the day (ex: Day Vig/Specific Scum - and I'm not guaranteeing this role will exist), [/u]someone must VOLUNTEER to be sacrificed to another player. The player sacrificed will NOT have their role revealed upon death. [/quote]Okay, so someone must volunteer to be sacrificed and their role will not be revealed. If all of town can agree no one will sacrifice themselves for the stone then we'll be okay. And if someone does sacrifice themselves, we can assume affterwards that they were scum, and if they choose who the stone goes to that person is also probably good chance of being scum[/quote] 2 points: 1. Day kill power is possible 2. If scum off themself, victim recipient is not necessarily scum but could be marked for death.
|
|
|
Post by Seth Dillinger on Feb 11, 2020 12:56:45 GMT -5
Right, Dylan can be town too.
Not sacrificing seems like the right play here. If scum get to a point where they have all the stones and want to do the sacrifice play to go for the cheap win, they can do that, but we shouldn't help them by making that stone easier to access. The Soul Stone doesn't even see that good?? Like, you make a dead player vote for you? Who the fuck cares?
If we deny scum the ability to get all the stones, they have to beat us the old fashioned way. Meanwhile, town still have a majority of the stones and can use their powers. Keep in mind if each ability is only usable once... we can also pass stones between people who we think are town so that we get multiple uses out of it. The ability to revive a dead townie ALONE should be crazy.
Imagine that we lynch town today. Whoever has the Time Stone should revive that townie. Then, pass the stone to them. Then that townie can revive another townie. Etc. The circle goes on. We run the risk of scum blocking it somehow I guess? But this game seems almost hilariously unloseable if town is smart and coordinated.
|
|
|
Post by Curtis D. Kanyon on Feb 11, 2020 13:06:02 GMT -5
Sounds like something scum would say. Can we sacrifice Seth for the soul stone right now?
|
|
|
Post by Dylan on Feb 11, 2020 13:06:21 GMT -5
But this game seems almost hilariously unloseable if town is smart and coordinated. We aren't exactly the smartest bunch, we'll find a way to lose :^) but wow yeah your time stone points bring up a great point. If we lynch someone, find out they're town, revive, rince and repeat we'd almost be able to go with no casualties this game. Because yaknow, nightkills will take us out too.
|
|
|
Post by Bobby Barratt on Feb 11, 2020 13:39:57 GMT -5
I think I am picking up on what Mongo is putting down with that sort of softclaim, and it isn't a cop. If it's what I think it is, then Mongo is quite smart to do what he's doing, actually. UNVOTEh2f reads as strong town to me right now. DT looks mostly good for at least bringing up the Soul Stone thing. So does johndoe -- I like that he's the only other person to engage in mechanical speculation with me about what to do with the Soul Stone. It feels like scum are maybe avoiding talking about the Soul Stone because they don't know whether it's the correct play or not? Which makes me FOS: Hype, Dunne, Ryan, BobbyI'm going to VOTE: Draven, however. I dislike that he basically starts spewing IIoA when he arrives in the thread. Like what did that summary post do? There are no opinions given, other than pointing out the obvious like "the Mongo wagon is without reason" (no shit, it's an RVS wagon) or "Seth has a point about the Soul Stone" (what point? I made two separate ones) or "Mongo claiming cop is very interesting" (this is nothing, this means nothing). Happy with my vote here for now. *removes one of his headphones and hits stop on the walkman* Wait, what? The only reason I haven't discussed the soul stone yet is because I don't think there's a discussion to be had at this point. In my opinion you've jumped right to the issue of effectively gung ho-ing a player and hoping for the rest of the game that scum don't steal it. I feel like it's a pointless discussion on day 1.
|
|