|
Post by Union Jack on Sept 4, 2019 1:50:19 GMT -5
Best Match: Worst Match: Best Segment: Worst Segment: Biggest Push:
Was your Character used correctly?:
Did The Show Flow Correctly?:
Additional: (If there is something you'd like to see more/less of, please let us know)
-What did you think of the BadStreet Scramble? There was some resistance to the "24/7" title style but we felt it worked well and gave this show a narrative. As such, we are considering making it a "Once per PPV rotation" theme. Opinions?
|
|
|
Post by robriot on Sept 4, 2019 4:20:24 GMT -5
Best Match: I really loved Rock Stone vs Tarrasque. Felt like a big time hoss fight. Worst Match: Nightshade vs. Archer. Not because the match was bad, but because I didn't feel like it needed to be particularly competitive. Nightshade was a no show. Best Segment: Archer again (see Billy, I do like him!). The card trick after his Badstreet Title shenanigans was inspired. Suits the character and also makes him threatening. Worst Segment:There were no bad segments guys. None. I don't want to put anything here, because nothing deserves singling out as a negative. Biggest Push: Probably good ol' Rob Riot and his hit job on Kintaru at the end. He felt like every inch the dangerous veteran.
Was your Character used correctly?: Absolutely, top to bottom. Great job.
Did The Show Flow Correctly?:Yes it did. I picked up on no continuity errors whatsoever.
Additional: (If there is something you'd like to see more/less of, please let us know) Here's where my one gripe is going. I know as well as anyone that there are times when shows fall behind or writers get busy, but as there are three of you on the case, at least one of you should have made a post or two on the forums. It was stone dead for almost a full week after the RP deadline expired, with no acknowledgement that anything was happening. Even now we've only got staff comments on two of the RPs, which isn't great. If people aren't getting RP feedback and regular communication from the staff, it's harder for them to feel invested. GCW will thrive if it's made to feel like a community, so make sure there's always a conversation happening. That's just my two cents.
-What did you think of the BadStreet Scramble? There was some resistance to the "24/7" title style but we felt it worked well and gave this show a narrative. As such, we are considering making it a "Once per PPV rotation" theme. Opinions? - I think it worked really well. As you've suggested, it probably shouldn't happen every week, but it was great entertainment while reading the show.
|
|
fowler
.::XHF Competitor::.
Posts: 159
|
Post by fowler on Sept 4, 2019 8:00:07 GMT -5
Best Match: Rock Stone vs Tarrasque Great intro to the event, reminded me how good you guys are at writing "hardcore" style matches, and felt like it meant something which it did.
Worst match: Don't think there was one.
Best segment: Seems wrong to comment on my own character but I have to say Archer and Tarrasque. I really enjoyed their interaction and the card tricks. It established Archer as he was in the last run of GCW.
Worst Seg: Again don't think there is one.
Biggest push: Has to be Archer. Like Rob commented, he was built to be a threat and to walk away with the Badstreet Title is no mean feat.
Character use: Was excellent. I know that I can leave my character in your hands and have no worries which is one of the best parts of GCW.
Flow: Excellent, I enjoyed the read and pace.
Additional and Scramble: I would echo Rob that community is the key making any fed thrive, so let's try and keep the conversations going. (this is for all of us to do) The scramble worked really well I thought, but definitely don't over do it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 4, 2019 13:56:01 GMT -5
Hey guys, just popping in here after doing all the Roleplay feedbacks lol and i’m Kinda glad I did that first lol
I agree, feedback needs to happen consistently and communication must be key, this was very much a case of Tom and I had separate family trips and I was an idiot and ate a cookie that contained the devil, not any indication of lack of interest or want. I put off the remaining feedback until after results because I felt priority went to getting the show out, then work, so I finished up and checked for show feedback.
Honestly i’m Glad people agree that the feedback helps keep people interested. I will be more diligent going forward, things just got away from me a little bit.
All that said, thanks for the feedback and for being honest about things that will need to be kept up as we go forward.
|
|
|
Post by Union Jack on Sept 4, 2019 14:04:39 GMT -5
If I'm being completely honest, I hate public roleplay feedback and probably wont be giving it regularly. This is mainly because I am an excited child and tend to mark out a bit which makes me think my giving feedback makes it ridiculously obvious who wins and loses in my book... Perhaps I'll do what D has just done and give public feedback AFTER the results go live to keep the suspense for the show.
That being said... I actually love talking with you all about your storylines, creative direction and inspiration for the characters and am happy to give full feedback and stuff via PM - As I have already done with several people. Usually I wait to be asked for this, but I'd be happy to start reaching out to more of you (I understand without receiving feedback you can become disheartened and get the impression nobody is reading your work)
|
|
|
Post by tuckerblane on Sept 24, 2019 9:23:48 GMT -5
I think staff feedback is important, but as the boss man pointed out, it’s probably best to keep that private. Since this is a forum-based fed as opposed to a site-based fed, does that mean us non-staff members can leave comments under RPs? I’m just talking about quick, constructive critiques. No need to openly trash someone. That’s kind of a dick move.
|
|
|
Post by robriot on Sept 24, 2019 10:38:47 GMT -5
Yep, anybody can comment unless the OP has locked the post
|
|