Battle of the Bands U-Pick

[RattyMcDaddy]

Let's get this show moving, I'll start this train. For the same reason we got Mav. 

Vote Dunne

[Dylan]

I mean I'm at a pass for what to do. I cannot make reads on anyone. I want to give everything a quick reread to maybe find vital information that could be hidden, but otherwise I'm probably gonna hop in that train too

[Steele]

OH CRAP

I completely forgot to end the day. In my defence, I did the shift I normally do on a Thursday today, so I’ve spent all day thinking it’s Thursday, not Monday.

So you basically had an extra 5 hours on top of the extra 4 or 5 I was already giving you... and you still didn’t lynch anyone. Jesus.

Anyway, no lynch happened. In the interests of consistency, here’s what happened:

Activity since last time:
Rat votes Dunne
That’s it

---

Votes:
Cross - 1 (Kuroi)
Kira - 1 (Hype)
Hype - 2 (Cross, Kira)
Dunne - 1 (Rat)

Not voting: DT, h2f, Dunne, Dylan Black, Mongo

It is now NIGHT TWO. Anyone with a night action please PM me with what you want to do. Night will end at 1900 BST (1400 ET) on Tuesday May 5.

[Steele]

The call goes out for the third round to begin, and everybody once again reports to the hall.

"Alright guys, better do a quick head count. Make sure you're all still here...

...seven, eight, nine... hold up - who's missing?"

Steele scans the crowd with a puzzled look on his face. Then he realises who's missing...

SPOILER: Click to show

{Spoiler}


"Oh, wait - I didn't see you back there. Silly me!

"Well, it looks like you're all still here. Which is good. For some of you. Ha!

"Alright, back to work. We'll catch the buggers yet."

---

Still Alive:

1. DT
2. Rat
3. Cross
4. h2f
5. Kira Izumi
6. Dunne
7. Kuroi
8. Dylan Black
9. Hype
10. Mongo

With 10 alive, it'll take 6 votes to lynch.

Day will end on FRIDAY MAY 8 at 1900 BST (1400 ET)

[ForeverKuroi]

Wait did someone die?

[Steele]

May 5, 2020 13:19:27 GMT -5 ForeverKuroi said:

Wait did someone die?

No

[ForeverKuroi]

May 5, 2020 13:32:21 GMT -5 Steele said:

May 5, 2020 13:19:27 GMT -5 ForeverKuroi said:

Wait did someone die?

No

Gotcha. Thanks.

Vote: DT

I'll read through what he says and let me know if we have a better pick, but that's my vote for now.

[Dave D-Flipz]

Care to elaborate?

[RattyMcDaddy]

You two ladies relax, we have tile to fight later, let's figure out why no one was removed, someone block someone last night? Doc save. Let's use some thinking and take advantage of this opportunity while it's here, then you two can duke it out.

[Dave D-Flipz]

I think it was likely a doctor save. I Still think cross is most suspicious but kuroi just also made my list. Not because he voted for me I kind of expect that at this point. But it doesn't fit. He was all over Dunne and everyone else was starting to come around because Dunne is doing nothing too help just shitposting. Suddenly he comes right out of the gate on me. I've Been playing and scum hunting. Why the sudden flip?

I have a good hunch on what role Hyperion has. And the reasoning I can't say without outing myself. But I'm not a rule cop and I think hype and probably h2f also get where I'm going. But on the off chance someone is a lie detector: I am town.

We know Kuroi isn't a cop so what happened overnight that made him switch from Dunne to me?

[ForeverKuroi]

May 2, 2020 23:03:59 GMT -5 Dave D-Flipz said:

*snip for brevity*Kira looks shady for talking too much. Kuroi looks shady for ... well being Kuroi. Dylan looks shady for lurking then popping up when people start to call him on it. It's the same every game.

That last line shows you're not reading close enough into it. I've done nothing shady at all this game. You're probably right about Dylan. Kira talks a lot because of the theme. It's no surprise Kira likes music.

*snip*I tend to die in these things. SO unless someone slips and gives us something to go on ... the scummy things so far are Cross trying to roll train on Hype with shoddy reasoning, Mongo and Kira having linked bands, Dylan's band having a VERY obvious song that also ties to a role we've seen that is bad for town, and Kuroi just doing his usual acting shady to make sure scum doesn't kill him/we can't tell what he's doing.

Simply writing me off as shady is lazy play. Hype has shoddy reasoning? Where? And I don't see Cross doing anything immediately shady. This is his first game with no established history.

May 3, 2020 0:09:45 GMT -5 Hyperion said:

Mongo is stupid, let's just get that clear.

Here here!

But him and Kira spouting lyrics from the same artists sounds too convenient.

I feel the connections of bands for scum is really lame. I don't think they'd advertise that if that's the case.

Dylan's nonsensical comments with lyrics make me feel like he's playing a 'whatever' game, and that makes me think he's town.

Probably the wrong conclusion. He's not scum hunting.

H2F is from a band that is more musical instruments than words. Maybe an orchestra? Maybe she's 'orchestrating' something for us?

...What

Kuroi is quite.

Quite good looking? Quite charming?

Too quote for a man that is usually a busy scum hunter. I know he's busy IRL, but this does seem off.

I AM NOT TOO QUOTE! But the weekends are generally bad for me. Especially since I don't have a computer working unless I'm at work, which I am now.

So... Vote: Kira, based on absolutely nothing other than I'm familiar with his playstyles, and also note that I could be reading this all wrong. Get your hands off of my woman, motherfuckerrrrr

Bad vote, but not the worst.

From Kira:

take a look at these quotes i've gotten from the last two pages and see what they have in common. well they have in common it's DT and Hype posting these comments, but other than that. it's leaning way too heavy and way too hard on the fact me and mongo were given two former beatles as our characters. 6 different instances in only two pages and one day. that's pushing and trying to insinuate far too much something between mongo. honestly this double teaming between both DT and Hype feels incredibly scummy. Why else go this hard on something that could be so trivial unless you're scum and you want one of us dead during the day round? why try to push this hard and get a possible lynch on two people you both know are town? to see if your hunch is correct? is that it? then when you kill one of us i bet the next will go very soon afterwards. i say we get rid of these two before they take out two town this round.

Vote: Hype

when he turns up scum your next DT.

This is OMGYS because it's voting because that person voted you. With that said, I'm finding an unusual but not scum vibe from Kira. I think he might be gaining confidence.

May 3, 2020 6:54:20 GMT -5 h2f said:

It doesn't seem like their's a consensus on acting the most scummy.

I agree with a number of points being said but am not sure the 'kill 'em and if they turn up town too bad' strategy is best. I disagree with a random vote day 1 for this reason. If a train starts, I may join if the logic is sound. Honestly, I'm just glad we are moving away from posting ONLY lyrics. It's good to have something to go on.

FOS DUNN

H2F sounds like she's on the ball.

May 3, 2020 8:36:10 GMT -5 Mongo the Destroyer said:

May 3, 2020 7:42:57 GMT -5 h2f said:

Dear Dave,

No.

1. As previously discussed, I think by you, the band is NOT indicative of the role. Follow your own damn logic consistently for at least a day.

2. I am fairly certain that godfather was not the role Hyperion thought I have. It isn't me but I think I know what he's talking about.

FOS DAVE

lmao

The level of salt in this has made my evening

Mongo, stop making me not want to hate you.

May 3, 2020 8:56:26 GMT -5 Dylan said:

Did somebody ask for more song lyrics with no meaning? Gotcha

FOS: Dunne, who's added nothing relevant to the game so far

Meaningless following under the radar.

May 3, 2020 23:12:30 GMT -5 Dylan said:

I mean I'm at a pass for what to do. I cannot make reads on anyone. I want to give everything a quick reread to maybe find vital information that could be hidden, but otherwise I'm probably gonna hop in that train too

I'll be shocked if this happens.

May 5, 2020 14:15:39 GMT -5 Dave D-Flipz said:

I think it was likely a doctor save.

That was my first thought too, but DT's good enough to fake that stuff like Rat did with the silence in the last mafia game.

I Still think cross is most suspicious but kuroi just also made my list. Not because he voted for me I kind of expect that at this point. But it doesn't fit. He was all over Dunne and everyone else was starting to come around because Dunne is doing nothing too help just shitposting.

...Did you not see my reasoning for voting Dunne? It was basically a joke vote, a random vote based off nothing. You're my first actual suspicion. Look at the posts yourself.

Apr 28, 2020 17:27:20 GMT -5 ForeverKuroi said:

OK so the band I thought H2F had, Bailey has.

And Dave has the obvious one, the one I'd know he have before he even had it. Half his t-shirts have the band name, at least from the original XHF days.

Anyways, I should vote.

Vote: Dunne I don't know your band and I'm insecure.

Apr 29, 2020 10:04:29 GMT -5 h2f said:

Apr 29, 2020 7:56:02 GMT -5 mosler said:

[Watching all the bickering...]

Ladies, ladies.....







Are we not men?

nope.

Best response.

Now let's kill the guy I voted and let this be Dunne and over with.[/quote]

I have a good hunch on what role Hyperion has. And the reasoning I can't say without outing myself. But I'm not a rule cop and I think hype and probably h2f also get where I'm going. But on the off chance someone is a lie detector: I am town.

We know Kuroi isn't a cop so what happened overnight that made him switch from Dunne to me?

Lie detectors can't test for that. Dude, I have to say if you are town, you are lacking a bit here. I love you, but I think you're scum and your post suggests you're reaching.

[ForeverKuroi]

May 5, 2020 13:47:13 GMT -5 Dave D-Flipz said:

Care to elaborate?

Absolutely not.

[RattyMcDaddy]

Damn Kuroi unleashing, could be lack of a kill frustration, and blaming Doctor Dave for the save, maybe?

I'll reserve my judgement though.

[Hyperion]

May 5, 2020 15:19:43 GMT -5 RattyMcDaddy said:

Damn Kuroi unleashing, could be lack of a kill frustration, and blaming Doctor Dave for the save, maybe?

I'll reserve my judgement though.

Uh, you just judged though. And you might be right. However you were the first to mention a doctor, so I have to wonder if you know more than you are letting on. IE; you are a Doctor, or your kill attempt was stopped.

I'd like to know more why DT is a target, he isn't striking me too much as town or scum. But I'm open to Kuroi's reads. No reads however sounds like what Rat was hinting at, a vengeance vote.

Kira seems off to me but looking at it through other eyes, maybe he is just inspired because it's music theme. I know he likes music so makes sense.

Dunne's shitposting doesn't seem scummy to me, more a sign of a new player not really sure what to post. He's played like that before too if I'm thinking of the same stuff.

Honestly, this Kuroi/ DT thing is probably one to watch. Let's see what they dig up, in a battle of 'Told You So'.

[Hyperion]

May 5, 2020 14:15:39 GMT -5 Dave D-Flipz said:

But on the off chance someone is a lie detector: I am town.

This is a strange thing to say, seeing as nobody has mentioned lie detectors before. Kinda sounds like you are fishing for roles by saying this. Or, you are the lie detector and want to test someone. Very strange time to mention this.

I am Town btw.