Battle of the Bands U-Pick

[RattyMcDaddy]

May 5, 2020 18:32:12 GMT -5 Dave D-Flipz said:

No we had one in a previous game where mav was town but won with scum and was going against town even though he didn't know who scum was and they didn't know he existed. I only suggested it because Judas is one of the most well known songs by Dylan's band Fozzy and Judas is like the most well known traitor in history.

Though my opinion has changed on that as again bands aren't supposed to be alignment indicative.

If that's your only argument against Dylan, Dunne has done that worse so why joke about Dunne but be serious about Dylan that he's your secondmost likely scum?

I follow you with Dylan, that song seems like much to obvious of an option though seeing if someone found out his band, and we have all been flaunting our bands pretty clearly. Seems as if he let that cat out of the bag with the band, the clear assumption would be Judas.

Imo kira was playing differently, and has stopped once it was mentioned, and Mongo has been extremely un-Mongo like after someone brought up there may be a connection between the two.

Cross and Dunne have both been silent for the better part of a day, so do we chalk that up to inactive, or to watching us all argue like clowns while they plot away?

[ForeverKuroi]

May 5, 2020 18:32:12 GMT -5 Dave D-Flipz said:

No we had one in a previous game where mav was town but won with scum and was going against town even though he didn't know who scum was and they didn't know he existed. I only suggested it because Judas is one of the most well known songs by Dylan's band Fozzy and Judas is like the most well known traitor in history.

Though my opinion has changed on that as again bands aren't supposed to be alignment indicative.

If that's your only argument against Dylan, Dunne has done that worse so why joke about Dunne but be serious about Dylan that he's your secondmost likely scum?

That sounds like a different way to describe the same role I was describing.

And the difference between Dylan and Dunne is that Dunne isn't even attempting to play this game, from what I say. Maybe I need to reexamine.

Everyone else doesn't seem to be incredibly scummy. Next would be Kira, but something tells me he might be town.

[ForeverKuroi]

So being a fellow AWF admin, I've been able to pinpoint general waking hours (although I can't figure out Ryan) and Bailey/Cross is awake from like 10-11 PM EST to like 4 PM EST. Unlike the rest of the Brits, he sleeps responsibly for his time zone.

My guess regarding Dunne is he joins these games because he loves the flavor/theme, but isn't too interested in Mafia. (Almost the opposite of me)

And I'm honestly not too sure how closely related bands are to roles. For instance, I don't see the connection from my role to my band.

[Steele]

Vote count 3.1

DT - 1 (Kuroi)

---

I know the day is only a few hours old but I’ll prod the least active who are getting mentioned a fair bit.

The Dunne Deal
Cross Recoba

I’m leaving Dylan off this list cos he was active right before the previous day ended so he gets a pass for now.

[The Dunne Deal]

Sup guys, sorry about not being active recently, My depression was kicking my ass, so I was popping in to read, and not much else. same thing with discord. Hopefully I can get in to see my doctor tomorrow and get my scrips refilled.

[The Dunne Deal]

Also my not playing "correctly" I love both suspicious and not suspicious. Therefor confusing both sides of the game. I'm I one the side of the Town or am I Scum. You don't know. 

[Kira Izumi]

Some of you sitting there with yer cock in yer hand
Don't get you nowhere don't make you a man
I heard something 'bout my Ma and my Pa
They didn't want me so they made me a star

i still say hype and dt are scummy to me. my last long post with tons of quotes says why i think this. i didn't vote for hype because he voted me either. that's stupid and petty. stupid and petty only makes town lose and help scum win, or vice versa. i voted him because i think he was scummy. although to get something happening, and since i feel dt is also scummy and he has one vote on him already,

i'll Vote: DT

for now.

[Mongo the Destroyer]

Aright, wow you guys wrote a lot.

So I'll dive straight in:
Vote: DT
FOS: Hype

I've thought a lot about it but although DT claims otherwise, it seems a lot like they're fishing for roles.

Both have multiple times suggested that Kira and I are either masons or scum- that's pressure to role reveal
DT right away after nobody died: "OH MAYBE WE HAVE A DOCTOR"
Also this lie detector thing? Our cop is dead and I lasted a whole game as a "lie detector" so it's not hard to stay safe if there is a doctor. They'd speak up probably

"I want to know who I can trust" easily translates to "I want to know who to kill first"

I'm not buying it, bro

"It's a tug of war
Though I know I mustn't grumble
It's a tug of war
But I can't let go
If I do you'll take a tumble
And the whole thing is going to crumble
It's a tug of war"

[RattyMcDaddy]

May 5, 2020 19:11:25 GMT -5 ForeverKuroi said:

So being a fellow AWF admin, I've been able to pinpoint general waking hours (although I can't figure out Ryan) and Bailey/Cross is awake from like 10-11 PM EST to like 4 PM EST. Unlike the rest of the Brits, he sleeps responsibly for his time zone.

My guess regarding Dunne is he joins these games because he loves the flavor/theme, but isn't too interested in Mafia. (Almost the opposite of me)

And I'm honestly not too sure how closely related bands are to roles. For instance, I don't see the connection from my role to my band.

It says in the rules of the game, bands play no bearing on the role, the song you were given does........this may lead me to believe you were not given a song, Kuroi?

[Mongo the Destroyer]

May 5, 2020 19:58:17 GMT -5 RattyMcDaddy said:

May 5, 2020 19:11:25 GMT -5 ForeverKuroi said:

So being a fellow AWF admin, I've been able to pinpoint general waking hours (although I can't figure out Ryan) and Bailey/Cross is awake from like 10-11 PM EST to like 4 PM EST. Unlike the rest of the Brits, he sleeps responsibly for his time zone.

My guess regarding Dunne is he joins these games because he loves the flavor/theme, but isn't too interested in Mafia. (Almost the opposite of me)

And I'm honestly not too sure how closely related bands are to roles. For instance, I don't see the connection from my role to my band.

It says in the rules of the game, bands play no bearing on the role, the song you were given does........this may lead me to believe you were not given a song, Kuroi?

:thinking:

Now that's a good catch, Rat

Still don't trust DT more but we'll have to keep a watch on Kuroi

[Mongo the Destroyer]

May 5, 2020 19:59:53 GMT -5 Mongo the Destroyer said:

May 5, 2020 19:58:17 GMT -5 RattyMcDaddy said:

It says in the rules of the game, bands play no bearing on the role, the song you were given does........this may lead me to believe you were not given a song, Kuroi?

:thinking:

Now that's a good catch, Rat

Still don't trust DT more but we'll have to keep a watch on Kuroi

But I just checked and it's role madness, so theoretically even scum have roles and Kuroi just didn't word it well

[RattyMcDaddy]

May 5, 2020 20:01:03 GMT -5 Mongo the Destroyer said:

May 5, 2020 19:59:53 GMT -5 Mongo the Destroyer said:

:thinking:

Now that's a good catch, Rat

Still don't trust DT more but we'll have to keep a watch on Kuroi

But I just checked and it's role madness, so theoretically even scum have roles and Kuroi just didn't word it well

Now you gave him an easy out, but I can agree with bad wording, he and I have had arguments over that type of stuff before

[The Dunne Deal]

I feel like we're at the part of the movie where no one trusts anyone and we're all standing around with our guns pointed at each waiting for the first mf'er to pull the trigger.

[RattyMcDaddy]

May 5, 2020 20:05:36 GMT -5 The Dunne Deal said:

I feel like we're at the part of the movie where no one trusts anyone and we're all standing around with our guns pointed at each waiting for the first mf'er to pull the trigger.

Looks like the idea is pulling the trigger on Dave.

[ForeverKuroi]

May 5, 2020 19:49:06 GMT -5 The Dunne Deal said:

Also my not playing "correctly" I love both suspicious and not suspicious. Therefor confusing both sides of the game. I'm I one the side of the Town or am I Scum. You don't know. 

Tell us your reads. That'd be a good place to start.